Friday, Sep 25, 1:00 – 2:00 PM Where: Bernie Milton PavilionThe Ithaca Commons Entry: $25 per contestant Register By Thursday, Sept 24 at 12:00 PM Every single pie is donated by Hollenbeck's Cider Mill in Virgil, baking since 1933. No pies, no contest. Three days of apples, cider, and music filling the Commons September 25 through 27. See the whole festival . The Great Apple Pie Eating Contest winner in 2025 View Event →